Paint by Numbers vs Freehand Painting: Honest Pros and Cons
Should you paint by numbers or learn to paint freehand? This is not an either/or question. They serve different purposes and many artists do both. Here is an honest breakdown of when each approach shines.
At ArtistryByNumbers: Free shipping to the US, Canada, the UK, the EU, Australia and New Zealand and Buy 2 Get 1 Free.
Want to paint this yourself?
Turn one of your own photos into a numbered canvas (from $19.95). We trace it, mix the paints to match, and ship the kit with brushes.
Or pick a ready-made design
- Bold and Free Painting by Numbers Premium Kit (from $19.95)
Freehand Painting
Pros
- Complete creative freedom, paint anything you imagine
- Develops original artistic skills
- Unique, one-of-a-kind results
- Deeply rewarding when you create something from nothing
Cons
- Steep learning curve, years of practice for good results
- Frustrating for beginners, blank canvas paralysis is real
- Expensive to learn, classes, supplies, multiple failed attempts
- Results not guaranteed, many beginners quit after disappointing first tries
Paint by Numbers
Pros
- No experience needed: stunning results from day one
- Guaranteed beautiful outcome, follow numbers, get art
- Teaches real painting skills (brush control, color recognition, layering)
- Relaxing and meditative, no performance pressure
- Affordable, everything included in the kit
- Perfect stepping stone to freehand painting
Cons
- Limited creative freedom (though you can customize)
- You paint someone else's design
- Some art purists dismiss it (unfairly, in our opinion)
The Best Path
Many successful artists followed this progression
- Start with paint by numbers: learn brush control, color handling, and the joy of painting without frustration
- Customize your kits: change colors, blend sections, add personal touches
- Try freehand with guidance: follow YouTube tutorials using skills you built with PBN
- Go fully freehand: create original art with confidence and skills you developed gradually
Paint by numbers is not a lesser form of painting. It is the on-ramp to a lifelong creative practice. Money-back guarantee.
Browse Kits | Create a Custom Kit
Free shipping to the US, Canada, the UK, the EU, Australia and New Zealand, with no minimum order. Buy two kits and the third is free, applied automatically at checkout.
