Paint by Numbers vs Adult Coloring Books: Which Creative Hobby Is Right for You?
Both paint by numbers and adult coloring books offer relaxation, creativity, and a satisfying finished product. But the experiences — and results — are very different. This honest comparison helps you decide which hobby fits your lifestyle, budget, and creative goals.
At ArtistryByNumbers, we obviously love paint by numbers — but we will give you the honest truth about both options. Free Worldwide Shipping and Buy 2 Get 1 Free.
The Experience
Paint by Numbers
You work with actual acrylic paint on canvas, using brushes to fill in numbered sections. The tactile experience — the feel of brush on canvas, the thickness of real paint, the satisfaction of covering a section — is deeply satisfying. Sessions last 20-60 minutes and the meditative quality is strong.
Adult Coloring Books
You use colored pencils, markers, or gel pens on printed paper. The experience is more portable and less messy. Quick to start, easy to pause, and requires no setup or cleanup. Sessions can be as short as 5 minutes.
The Finished Result
This is where the difference is dramatic:
- Paint by numbers produces a real painting on canvas that you can frame and hang on your wall. It looks like genuine art. Visitors will not know you painted it by numbers.
- Coloring books produce a colored page in a book. While beautiful, it stays in the book or requires scanning/framing to display. It always looks like a colored page.
Side-by-Side Comparison
- Setup time: PBN 5 min | Coloring 0 min
- Cleanup: PBN 5 min (rinse brushes) | Coloring 0 min
- Portability: PBN low | Coloring high
- Cost per project: PBN $20-50 | Coloring $1-3 per page
- Finished product: PBN canvas painting | Coloring paper page
- Display value: PBN high (wall art) | Coloring low
- Skill development: PBN high (real painting skills) | Coloring moderate
- Relaxation: PBN high | Coloring high
- Messiness: PBN moderate | Coloring none
Our Verdict
If you want a quick, portable creative fix — coloring books win. If you want a deeper creative experience that produces real art for your home — paint by numbers is the clear winner. Many of our customers started with coloring books and upgraded to paint by numbers when they wanted more substance from their hobby.
No experience needed for either. Joined by thousands of painters worldwide. Money-back guarantee.
👉 Try Paint by Numbers | Create a Custom Kit
Free Worldwide Shipping • Buy 2 Get 1 Free